What we priced
Printed car door magnets on 30 mil magnetic sheeting, full color, gloss overlaminate, square cut, with half an hour of layout and proof per order. The rates are the starter library examples: magnetic sheeting at $2.10 a square foot with 10 percent waste, ink at $0.18 a square foot, laminate at $0.45 with 15 percent waste, printer time at $20 an hour, design at $30, fabrication at $28, 18 percent overhead and a 40 percent target margin. The price is rounded up to the next $5. Margin means profit divided by price; markup vs margin for sign shops explains why a 40 percent markup is a smaller number.
| Fact | Detail |
|---|---|
| Material | 30 mil printable magnetic sheeting with bleed and waste |
| Finish | Overlaminate, square cut |
| Fixed time per order | 0.5 hr layout and proof, 0.2 hr printer setup, 0.1 hr cutting and packing |
| Overhead and margin | 18 percent overhead, 40 percent target margin |
| Tool used | SignEstimator, plans from $24 a month billed yearly or $49 billed monthly |
What one pair of 12 x 24 magnets is made of
| Line | Quantity | Cost |
|---|---|---|
| Magnetic sheeting 30 mil | 4.1 sq ft with bleed | $9.53 |
| Ink | 4.1 sq ft | $0.74 |
| Overlaminate | 4.1 sq ft | $2.14 |
| Print and laminate | 0.27 hr | $5.40 |
| Layout and proof | 0.5 hr | $15.00 |
| Square cut and packing | 0.1 hr | $2.80 |
| Direct cost | $35.61 | |
| Overhead at 18 percent | $6.41 | |
| Cost with overhead | $42.02 | |
| Price at 40 percent margin | $75.00 |
The magnetic sheeting is $9.53, about 27 percent of direct cost. Layout and proof is $15, or 42 percent. On a single pair the customer is mostly paying for the file, not the magnet. A shop that prices magnets by the square foot of material sees the smaller number and misses the bigger one.
Car magnet price by size for one pair
| Size of one magnet | Cost with overhead | Price per pair | Price per magnet |
|---|---|---|---|
| 12 x 6 in | $33.90 | $60 | $30.00 |
| 12 x 18 in | $37.93 | $65 | $32.50 |
| 12 x 24 in | $42.02 | $75 | $37.50 |
| 18 x 24 in | $49.90 | $85 | $42.50 |
Going from 12 by 18 to 18 by 24 doubles the area and adds only $20 to the pair. The material grows, the layout does not. That is why a small magnet quoted from area alone lands below cost, as the next table shows.
Car magnet price per piece from one truck to a fleet
| Order of 12 x 24 magnets | Vehicles | Cost with overhead | Price | Price per magnet |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2 | 1 | $42.02 | $75 | $37.50 |
| 4 | 2 | $58.41 | $100 | $25.00 |
| 6 | 3 | $74.71 | $125 | $20.83 |
| 10 | 5 | $107.37 | $180 | $18.00 |
| 20 | 10 | $189.04 | $320 | $16.00 |
| 50 | 25 | $434.02 | $725 | $14.50 |
The first pair carries the whole layout. By the second vehicle the price per magnet has fallen by a third, and after ten pieces the curve flattens, because what is left is sheeting, ink, laminate and print time that grow with every piece. On the 50 piece order the sheeting is $238.26, about 65 percent of direct cost, so a change in the magnet price from your supplier matters far more on fleet orders than on a single pair.
A fleet customer usually asks for a price per vehicle. In this example that is $75 for one truck, $50 a truck for two and $29 a truck for 25. Quote the order, not the unit, or the shop either loses the small job or overprices the big one.
What a flat $12 per square foot does to the same magnets
Many shops price magnets at one rate per square foot of magnet. Here is that habit at $12 a square foot against the line by line estimate.
| Job | Area | Flat $12 per sq ft | Cost with overhead | Estimated price | Result at the flat rate |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pair of 12 x 6 in | 2 sq ft | $24 | $33.90 | $60 | $9.90 loss |
| Pair of 12 x 24 in | 4 sq ft | $48 | $42.02 | $75 | 12.5 percent margin |
| Pair of 18 x 24 in | 6 sq ft | $72 | $49.90 | $85 | 30.7 percent margin |
| 10 of 12 x 24 in | 20 sq ft | $240 | $107.37 | $180 | $60 above the estimate |
| 50 of 12 x 24 in | 100 sq ft | $1,200 | $434.02 | $725 | $475 above the estimate, bid likely lost |
The flat rate loses money on small magnets and gives fleet orders to the shop down the road. Nothing on the flat rate sheet is wrong except that it has one number for two different kinds of cost.
What laminate, contour cutting and door lettering change
The same pair of 12 by 24 magnets without laminate drops to $70. Contour cutting the pair to the shape of a logo adds plotter time and moves the cost from $42.02 to $44.62, which stays inside the same $75 price after rounding; on a 50 piece order the cut time is a real line. When the customer wants permanent lettering instead of magnets, quote it as vehicle graphics with install time, as the truck lettering prices page does, and for full and partial wraps use the vehicle wrap estimating software page with its six van fleet example.
Fleet orders also mean a list of drivers, vehicles and contact details from the customer. Keep that list with the quote and not in a dozen email threads; a company that has to answer a data access request from one of its drivers will thank you for it, and tools such as Obtainer exist for exactly that search.
Who this pricing method is for and who it is not for
It fits a sign shop or print shop that sells car magnets next to banners, decals and vehicle lettering, quotes them one order at a time and wants the short order and the fleet order to clear the same margin. It also fits an estimator who answers price requests by email and needs a number in minutes.
It does not fit a business that sells stock magnets through an online cart at fixed prices, or a buyer looking for a free magnet calculator. SignEstimator is paid software with no free plan; the demo prices one job without an account.
How to quote car magnets in SignEstimator
Pick the decals, stickers, labels and magnets template, set the size of one magnet and the quantity, choose magnetic sheeting, laminate and the cut type. Your sheeting, ink and laminate prices come from your library, and print, layout and cutting hours from your labor rates. You see cost, price and real margin, edit any line and send a branded PDF quote or a link the customer approves online. The decal pricing software page shows the same template on sticker and label runs from 50 to 1,000 pieces.
| Plan | Billed yearly | Billed monthly |
|---|---|---|
| Solo | $24 per month | $49 per month |
| Shop | $74 per month | $149 per month |
| Team | $199 per month | $399 per month |
| Multi-location | $449 per month | $899 per month |
The full comparison is on the sign estimating software pricing page.