Skip to content
SignEstimator

· 5 min read

Sign shop estimating software, and how to test it on three jobs you already finished

Sign shop estimating software is worth buying only if it prices your finished jobs close to what they really cost. The fastest check is a back test. Take three jobs you have already completed, enter them in the tool with your own rates, and compare its cost to your actual cost and its price to your invoice. A tool that lands within about 5 percent on all three is accurate enough to trust. One that misses the install or the lift is not.

Demos always look good because the vendor picks the job. A back test uses yours. This article gives the method, a worked example with numbers, and the vendor answers that should end the conversation. SignEstimator is our product. We run the same test on it and tell you where it needs your input.

Sign shop estimator at a desk with drawings and a tablet
01 Demo
01 Demo

Estimate this job

Describe a sign job or upload the customer's photo. You get line items, a sale price and the margin in about a minute.

Uploading...
miles

No account needed for your first estimate.

Pick three jobs that hurt

Choose finished jobs with known actual cost, not your best ones.

  1. A lit sign, such as channel letters or a cabinet, because LEDs, power supplies and install height make it the hardest to price.
  2. A flat job, such as ACM, a banner or a vinyl package, because waste on sheet goods decides the margin.
  3. An install heavy job, such as a monument or a wall sign needing a lift, because crew hours and travel are where estimates are weakest.

For each, pull the invoice, the material receipts and the crew and machine hours. If you do not track hours, use the best honest estimate. You need a number to compare against, not a perfect one.

One back test, tool estimate against what the job really cost

These are example figures for a lit cabinet job. Rates are example rates: ACM at $92 a sheet, router $65 an hour, install crew $60 per person hour, overhead 20 percent of cost.

Line Your actual Tool estimate Gap
Sheet goods $1,380.00 $1,288.00 $92.00 under
Router hours $715.00 $585.00 $130.00 under
Install crew $840.00 $840.00 none
LEDs and power supplies $640.00 $640.00 none
Direct cost $3,575.00 $3,353.00 $222.00 under
Overhead at 20 percent $715.00 $670.60 $44.40 under
Total cost $4,290.00 $4,023.60 $266.40 under, 6.2 percent

The tool missed by 6.2 percent, and the cause is plain. It assumed 14 sheets where the floor used 15, and 9 router hours where the floor logged 11. Neither is a flaw in the arithmetic. They are inputs, and a good tool lets you change the waste factor and the machine time on that sign template once and have every later quote carry the fix.

Run the test with that in mind. The first result tells you how close the defaults are. The second result, after you adjust the template, tells you whether the tool can be taught. A tool that cannot be tuned stays 6 percent off forever.

Answers that should end the conversation

  • "Pricing is per square foot." Lit signs are priced from parts. A flat rate cannot see LED count.
  • "Install is a percentage of the sale." Install is crew size times hours plus lift and travel, and it changes per site. See how to quote sign installation.
  • "Overhead is built in." You need to set your own overhead and see it as a line.
  • "Margin is the markup you enter." Markup and margin are not the same, and a 40 percent markup is a 28.6 percent margin. The math is in markup vs margin for sign shops.
  • "Rates are industry standard." Your router, crew and material costs are yours.
  • "Per-user pricing we can discuss." Seat fees grow with the shop, so ask for the three year total. Sign shop software cost shows it by headcount.

Estimating tool or full shop system

You need Look at
Accurate quotes from your own rates, fast An estimating engine such as SignEstimator
Production, scheduling and invoicing in one place A shop management system such as shopVOX, SignTracker or CoreBridge
Estimate against actual hours Job costing, on the Team plan here, see sign shop job costing software
Accepted quotes into QuickBooks Online or Xero Sign shop QuickBooks integration, Shop plan and up

Many shops start with the estimating engine, because a wrong quote cannot be fixed by good scheduling later. The best sign shop software roundup compares the categories, and the sign estimating software pricing page has the flat plan prices, from $24 a month billed yearly.

A back test you can finish in an afternoon

  1. List three jobs and their actual costs.
  2. Open the tool, set your real rates once.
  3. Enter each job and record the estimate and the margin it shows.
  4. Mark every line more than 5 percent off and ask why.
  5. Adjust the template and run job one again.

Do this on SignEstimator through the demo on the homepage, then on any rival you are considering. The numbers decide, not the pitch. For the cost definitions behind a fair comparison, the IRS guide to business expenses lists what counts as a cost of doing business. If a lender or investor asks for job level margins, the same clean numbers feed the kind of reporting that larger companies handle with investor relations software for issuers.

02 Questions
02 Questions

Frequently asked questions

[email protected]